[YT] @v030201
LOL just by comparing Kimberley’s &曼青’s performances, I do think Kimberley deserved that 21 more than 曼青.
It is a big and hard song to perform, and yes Kimberley’s abit too naive to express it emotionally. But she did knock 曼青 down by her technique and I dont think there’s anything wrong with that.
If Kimberley did a good job on emotional expression as well, then she wouldve got 25 but not 21.
It is a fair mark.
[YT] @onlymes did u read and understand the lyrics?
You think she described what the song is about?
Or did she just hit all the notes?
This song requires much experience to perform, not every song can be a American classic.
[YT] I am more concerned why Zeng Zhi Hao was handpicked to PK with his dad? I got this thinking that just becos his dad is a celebrity, they wants to guarantee him a spot in Top 10! The PKers might have drawn him instead and he probably will be out. Although he is out this coming week but to me this is unfair to other contestants, maybe Chen Yi En would have got into Top 10 instead.
[YT] I am more concerned why Zeng Zhi Hao was handpicked to PK with his dad? I got this thinking that just becos his dad is a celebrity, they wants to guarantee him a spot in Top 10! The PKers might have drawn him instead and he probably will be out. Although he is out this week but to me this is unfair to other contestants, maybe Chen Yi En would have got into Top 10 instead.
[YT] @littlebreadw
I totally agree with your statement..just like “charice pempengco”!!
She’s from Philippine and yet she got a huge name being created in the States by the assistance and nurture of Oprah Winfrey and David Foster =)
[YT] 看到下面的一些comments我不知道为什么有些人就这么反感从小training唱歌的孩子, 他们有错吗? 你们怎么知道他们就不喜欢唱歌? 赤裸裸的嫉妒. 下面说kimberley cannot handle this song的朋友更是有够funny, she did hit all those notes. 嗓子不够厚不代表她的power没有够, she’s only 15. and whitney cant sing this piece now, just go check her live performances.
[YT] hopefully 張宇 will be there next week,
remember when he left as a team leader, 陶子 asked him to come back when there is ten contestants left
I think 張宇 is probably the fairest judge 星光’s had, other than maybe 小虎
[YT] totally agree with @jibikao What you said really make sense. Chinese show sing english song….and this episode is like…..totally crap…more than 50% of either the contestant or pkers sang English Song….
[YT] @vanegaop I am just saying that the Producer on the show shouldn’t allow that many English songs on one day and that I want to be impressed by Chinese songs more than English songs. And I am looking forward to next round because I am hoping more of them would choose Chinese songs. Most PKers are so good and yet “boring” and that is a problem that they need to figure out. Ex: Alisa did poorly on her first album.. T_T
[YT] @MrHuangtong Sorry I don’t know how to type Mandarin. I haven’t learned that and it takes forever to type a paragraph if I try to find a program to translate the whole thing. The problem with those “awesome” singers is that they are just “awesome” but nothing special (yet). They are so good at singing and yet boring… I don’t mind listening to English songs but more than half are English songs and it’s ridiculous. We will see next round!
[YT] @jibikao
you speak my mind, amen to this! Come on, sing some chinese songs, what’s with a chinese program singing English? No offense though, they’re awesome in their ways. But impress us with Chinese, please
[YT] @xdxhahaha what’s the point of finding pkers that can only do 18-20? The whole point of the pk contest is to let the contestants see the reality that they need to improve if they really want to become sucessful singers in the entertainment industry. In my opinion, if they can’t even beat the pkers, they shouldn’t be the winner of this contest.
[YT] @Faithpang945 That’s why Anthony is so good because he can impress us with his very ABC accent and when he sings English song, he sounds just as good. I won’t judge the PKers yet (those who sing English songs) until they’ve proven that their Chinese songs are just as good. I am just surprised that the Producer of this show allows that many people sing English songs. Sorry I can’t type Chinese (don’t know the spellings).
Well, hopefully the PKers can all sing Chinese songs next week and we’ll see how well they perform. I guarantee most of them do a lot worse than this week. It is easier to impress the audience with one song. The students have been judged for several months. They are competing against themselves and against the judges.
[YT] Please, bring that Beijing girl to US!!!!! She has the look and the international standard vocal. Make the Chinese singer shines in the world stage.
[YT] @jibikao totally agree with this..all the PKers sing well,but none of them sing a chinese song..ANTHONY in xing guang 5 can even sing a extremely good chinese song although he is an american,but why these PKers can’t?looking forward their chinese songs..
[YT] 曼青 very smart at picking song that suits her, but I was dissapointed when she didn’t have that braveness to fill the ‘blank’ between melody before the second refrain arrived, 07:42 to 07:75 just sounded so blank when she could’ve done some improvizations. :S
[YT] OMG, I love 边品宪 a lot, I just don’t know why everytimehe sang a song, it sounded very nice to listen, song that I don’t really like turned out to be very good, apparently his voice complimented every song he sang. He is my fave this season!
[YT] Yeah, PKers sing well but they are boring. No offense. I am not sure about you but when I choose to watch a Chinese show, I actually want to hear Chinese songs. I am waiting for one PKer that can impress me with a freaking CHINESE song. Yeah yeah yeah.. Whitney Houston… if I want to listen to English songs, I’ll watch American Idol.
The PKers sing great but boring. I fast forward 2 of them.